5 Comments

Manuscript


SoundEagle Reading

Manuscript Assessment Criteria

Reign not SoundEagle's Flight, For I seek thy Crested Might. has made the manuscript assessment criteria available as a thorough checklist for writers striving to improve their manuscripts for publication.

Rating

Click here to contact SoundEagle

A

B

C

D

F

X

ASPECTS
and
CRITERIA

G
R
E
A
T

G
O
O
D

F
A
I
R

P
O
O
R

F
A
I
L
E
D

N
A

COMMENTS

1. Genre

How well does the book fulfill the characteristics of the nominated genre?

2. Title

How well does the title reflect the content and direction of the book? Suggestions for alternative title:

3. Content

To what extent is the content of this book appropriate for the nominated audience?
Is the plot plausible?
To what extent is the story entertaining?
Is the plot developed at an appropriate and consistent pace?
How well is the major plot developed?
To what extent do subplots enrich the story?
Is the organisation of all elements of the plot tight and devoid of contradictions and inconsistencies?
To what extent are devices other than narrative (such as direct speech, diary entries, letters and newspaper reports) employed to develop the plot?
To what extent are individual chapters well organised โ€” each with a clear beginning, body and end?
Where given, are chapter titles relevant?

4. Narrative Style

To what extent does the narrative style enable the development of the plot?
How effective is the use of 1st person / 2nd person / 3rd person viewpoint?
Are techniques such as chronological-sequential narration, flashbacks and prequel-sequel narration effective in the book?

5. Characterization

Are there an appropriate number of characters?
Are all the characters relevant to the plot development and the setting, and to the depiction of major characters?
To what extent are the major characters well portrayed and developed (appearance, personality, manner, values, behaviour, strengths, weaknesses etc)?
To what extent are the minor characters well portrayed and developed (appearance, personality, manner, values, behaviour, strengths, weaknesses etc)?
To what extent are all the characters believable?
To what extent are these characters drawn so that the target audience can relate to them?

6. Dialogue

To what extent does each character use convincing and appropriate vocabulary and expression?
Is dialogue used effectively to depict characters?
Is the dialogue between characters believable and natural?
If characters use a language other than English, is it accurately written?
If characters use language that is written in a manner to suggest an accent or dialect, is the language consistent throughout the book?

7. Language

To what extent is the language of the book (narrative and dialogue) appropriate to the nominated audience?
To what extent does the author clearly communicate his/her concepts through the book?
Is the vocabulary accurately used in context?
Is unusual vocabulary (if applicable) explained within the context of the book?
Is the vocabulary rich and varied?
Is the expression clear?
Is the expression concise?
Is the spelling accurate?
Is correct grammar used throughout the manuscript?
Is the syntax accurate and flowing?
Is the punctuation correct throughout the book?
Are verb tenses used correctly throughout the book?

8. Setting

Is the setting vividly created?
Are details of the setting accurate?
To what extent does the setting help to develop the plot and/or characterization of the book?

9. Theme

Is the theme clearly articulated or implied in this book?

10. Illustrations

To what extent do the illustrations (such as diagrams, graphs, charts, tables, figures, clip arts, drawings, schematics, plans, maps, photos and/or statistical data) support or enhance the text of the book?

11. Technical Information

Is the technical information relevant and consistent?
Is the technical information convincing, up-to-date, and/or substantiated by references or citations?

12. Presentation

How effective is the layout (word spacing, line spacing, white space, margins, indentations, chapter headings and subheadings)?
How effective are the font selection(s) and size(s)?
How consistent is the spelling (where alternative spellings may be accurate but only one of the alternatives should be chosen and used throughout the manuscript)?
How consistent are the use of abbreviations and the use of numerals instead of words (or vice versa)?

13. Documentation

Is the referencing consistent, accurate and/or adequate?
Are appendices and other supporting materials required, appropriate and/or well-organised?
If required or present, are the title page, table of contents, acknowledgements, bibliography, reference list, index(es), synopsis and/or sleeve notes appropriate or satisfactory?
Reign not SoundEagle's Flight, For I seek thy Crested Might.

Overall Assessment

GRADE

Corresponding Readiness of the Manuscript

Comments

A

GREAT

Final Edit

B

GOOD

Constructive Edit + Final Edit

C

FAIR

Mentoring + Constructive Edit + Final Edit

D

POOR

Extensive Mentoring + Constructive Edit + Final Edit

F

FAILED

Unredeemable

Overall Grade and Evaluation:

Click here to contact SoundEagle

The DNA of a Successful Book [INFOGRAPHIC]

5 comments on “Manuscript

  1. Hi, I shared this post as well as the post “Writing” on my Twitter page. I consider these posts as very useful and hope my readers (more than 1.000 on Twitter) will find them useful too.

    Thank you for your efforts! Much appreciated!

    Best regards,
    Arlen

    Like

  2. Thank you very much. I appreciate your efforts as you have very unique blog! Wish you all te best in your future endeavouors!

    Arlen

    Like

  3. […] soundeagle.wordpress.com Rate this:Share thisFacebookTwitterะžะดะฝะพะบะปะฐััะฝะธะบะธะ’ะšะพะฝั‚ะฐะบั‚ะตMail.RuYouTubeLinkedInPinterestEmailPrintAM/ENAM/ESAM/FRAM/ITAM/DEAM/ROAM/GRAM/RUAM/GEAM/ILAM/AEAM/INAM/CNAM/JPLike this:Like12 bloggers like this. […]

    Like

  4. You put a lot of hard work into this piece, SoundEagle. It will help many writers who need good advice.
    blessings ~ maxi

    Like

โ„ โ… โ† Leave some thoughts or comments:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: